I know that there are many adult adoptees out there who sound angry. Many of us sound angry and frustrated with our lives, along with our constant asking of “what if?”. I know I am one of them. Although I wouldn’t consider myself to be “angry” these days, I definitely have been angry toward my adoption and I do still tend to focus on what my life would have been like had I not been adopted. It’s so easy for us to concentrate on the negative things surrounding our adoptions – to look at what we have lost by being pulled away from our countries/cultures of birth. And it’s really hard to “ignore” the yearning many of us have to go back and “be one” with our original countries, merely to attempt to be happy with ourselves and our identities the way everyone else around us seem to be. I’m sure there are people who read our blogs and our stories and think ‘if you’re so unhappy with having been adopted, what do you want? What is it that would make you happy?’. I’m aware that there are lots of adoptive parents these days who are attempting to bring up happy adoptive children, and to “make up” for what they think their children have lost. They’re also trying to do what they think our parents didn’t do, because ultimately, they probably don’t want their child/ren to be angry/ashamed the way my generation of adoptees has been.
Ideally, in answer to the above question, my answer would be something like: I want to be happy with who I am. I want to feel like a whole person, not one who’s always wandering around like a lost, confused soul. I want to be able to identify with the things and people I see around me. I want to understand who I am, and like so many people around me, I just want someone that I can look at and think from time to time ’so that’s where I got that trait from!’.
However, in thinking about adoption on a more worldly scale, and in trying to think outside of my own experiences, I have recently found myself wondering: is adoption a good thing? I’ve gone back and forth on this question throughout my life. And it’s really hard for me to come up with an answer to this question, because I struggle between my own inner experiences and the reality of what’s going on in the world.
As the year draws to a close, as Robert and I weigh up our finances and we both settle further into our jobs, I have been mentally creating a list of things I want to do when we travel to Korea next year, and when I go “home” for the first time since I was born. One thing I’d really like to do would be to go back to Eastern Social Welfare - to see what they’re like now and to see and experience the services they provide to Korea’s needy nowadays. Recently another adoptee went to an orphanage in Korea. Her post opened my eyes to the reality of such a small country in the world – and the fact that although I can be particularly emo about adoption, it doesn’t change the fact that there are many children out there who simply want a loving, caring home – loving parents to come home to every night, a meal on the table every night and the simple joy of knowing you’re loved by people they can call “family”.
In my fantasy world, there’s no such thing as adoption – no one would have to miss out on living happily around the countries, cultures and families they were originally brought into. We’d all be able to identify with those we see around us – we’d speak the languages that are “meant” to be spoken by us, and we’d just be the people we were “meant” to be from the very beginning. In thinking about my fantasy, it’s easy to justify my feelings of frustration and anger over not being able to identify with seemingly simple things. And it’s hard to accept that whether I like it or not, the world simply isn’t like that.
A couple of years ago, if someone had asked me, I would have told them that I was 100% against adoption. Why? Because I simply felt that adoption had caused me to feel insecure, angry, out of place and strange amongst the only world I knew and remembered. I couldn’t identify with my family, my “extended family” were like strangers to me and I just wanted to be in my world – the one I was born into. Although I still do believe that being adopted caused me to feel very insecure in my own skin, I now wonder: was this a selfish way of thinking?
Since getting married, I’ve never really considered adopting. Actually… I’ve never really considered adopting. Despite the fact that I’m terrified of any physical pain, if I ever had a family, I always wanted to have a child that was between me and whoever I got married to – to see a small me and him running around – to be lost in our own little world of our family. However, having seen only a small insight into what the wider world is really like, I wonder what it would be like to adopt – to adopt a child who actually needs certain things that I know Robert and I could provide.
What’s more important to me: my inner, personal struggles and battles or the wider world? What would all this mean if Robert and I were to have a family one day? I don’t believe that adoption is a GOOD DEED. Nor do I think it should be a simple matter - an easy solution - of starting a family when it’s not possible, biologically. I think it’s wrong to think ‘I can’t conceive? Meh. I’ll just adopt’. But it’s also hard to see what’s happening in the world today and not think a little bit outside of your own sphere.
Really… what’s more important? The issues we adoptees experience, or not living in an orphanage for the rest of your life?
Delicious
Digg This Post
Reddit
Stumble This Post
Related posts:
Tags: adoption, angry adoptee, the world
-
I guess this question is easy for me since I can’t identify many “issues” that adoptees face. I’d much rather grow up in a family than in an orphanage, even it means not speaking the language of my biological relatives. (I’m upset that I don’t speak Korean, but I’m equally upset that I don’t speak perfect French.)
I understand your point about people using adoption as their “meh” second choice after not being able to conceive naturally. (Though I’m pretty sure that’s why I have the family I do. I still don’t have any hard feelings about it.) Do you think adoption should be a choice from the beginning (People saying, “I want to adopt. Period.”) or do you think that no one should adopt?
-
I don’t always agree with you but I think you’re a very wise woman and I think you’ll be a fantastic mom.
When I was 18, I lived in Korea and I visited an orphanage and decided right then that I’d someday adopt a baby from there. That was the early 1980’s and it was 20 years before I eventually did adopt two children (but from Chinese orphanages). By then, I was 40 and my husband wanted biological children for all the reasons you mentioned (to see a little piece of himself, etc). But we lost three pregnancies and it was really heartbreaking because we wanted children for all of the selfish reasons ANY parents wants them. We weren’t looking to rescue anyone but it is an inescapable reality that adopting our daughters did spare them from a life without a family. I look at them and I don’t see orphans. I just see the beautiful faces of my children and even though they don’t miss all of the things you do, they probably will eventually and that’s why I read your blog. I want to help my beloved daughters find peace and happiness in the world with the hand they were dealt. If I could wave a magic wand and erase all the bad things from their life and put them back with their original family, I surely would. But the only thing I have control over is putting them back in the orphanage — not back with their family — and that’s unacceptable to me.
I’d love to adopt again (a dozen times!) but only children who are older and are on the verge of being turned out into a society that won’t support or understand or accept them. What happens to the 16 year old girl who is forced to leave the orphanage and has no work skills and no formal education and no family to fall back on if she can’t find housing or work? What will she be forced to do to survive? Who comforts her when she’s frightened or hurt? Just thinking about it breaks my heart.
What would you do to help her if you could?
-
I agree that adoption is not ideal and that in a perfect world, it would not exist. As background – I am Taiwanese American (husband is not Asian) and we adopted a child from Taiwan a few years ago. We also have a bio child. I have wanted to adopt since I read an article about it as a teenager. After reading several blogs on the topic, I’ve also been wondering if adoption really is a good thing.
However, I have met many adoptive parents and I don’t know a single one who did the “meh I’ll just adopt” thing. It was a very difficult decision for most, because they had to come to terms with the idea that they may never have a mini version of themselves running around. Many had to sit on the idea for a long time before they could truthfully say to themselves that they could love a non-bio child of another race. Contrary to what you may think, adoption is not the obvious choice for most people. I currently know 3 couples struggling with infertility (for over 2 years) and not once have any of them ever uttered the word “adoption”.
It’s not “a simple issue” at all. This is a life we’re taking responsibility for, it’s something most people take very, very seriously when making the decision to adopt.
We APs moan about the many hurdles we had to jump, but honestly, I’m GLAD those hurdles exist, because they’re there to weed out the “meh I’ll just adopt” people.
-
You’re right, that was too broad a statement. I don’t know most people. I am only speaking of those APs who I have met and talked to, as well as my own friends/family members who have dismissed adoption as an option even when they cannot conceive.
And you are probably right in that our experiences with APs have been vastly different. But what I meant to say is that of the people I know, the DECISION to adopt was taken very seriously, and was not “a simple thing” for any of them. For example, I talked to an AP who said it took her and her husband a long time to come to the decision to adopt, because they wanted to be sure they could love a child of another race. Another friend said she did not think she could love a non-bio child as much and thus will never adopt even though she cannot conceive.
Your point is not an invalid one by any means. At some point, I think some people (mostly women) who have been struggling with infertility will become so desperate that they will want a child by any means, and then, yes, adoption will come to mind. But of the people I know, it was never a “meh we’ll adopt” thing.
Please don’t think I meant to attack you. Your blog and others like it has educated me, an AP, a lot about the kinds of thoughts and questions an adoptee may have towards their own adoption and towards adoption in general. It has really changed my views on adoption and particularly transracial adoption. I’ve been extremely grateful that your blogs are out there.

8 comments
Comments feed for this article
Trackback link: http://seumnida.annyeong.net/wp-trackback.php?p=649